5735 Pillory Way
Indianapolis, IN 46254
3 bd 2 ba 1,499 sqft Built 1996 Lot 14,793 sqft single_family
Most recent sale
$249,900
May 12, 2022
Location
Timeline: Sale, Listing & Tax History
Recorded events
| Date | Event | Price | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sep 14, 2025 | Listed for rent | $1,680 | Zumper |
| Sep 13, 2025 | Listed for rent | $1,680 | Rently |
| Sep 5, 2025 | Listed for rent | $1,680 | Zumper |
| Sep 4, 2025 | Listed for rent | $1,680 | Rently |
| Aug 28, 2025 | Price changed for rent | $1,680 | Zumper |
| Aug 21, 2025 | Price changed for rent | $1,785 | Zumper |
| Aug 14, 2025 | Price changed for rent | $1,900 | Zumper |
| Jul 24, 2025 | Price changed for rent | $2,020 | Zumper |
| Jul 17, 2025 | Price changed for rent | $2,150 | Zumper |
| Jun 17, 2025 | Listed for rent | $2,265 | Zumper |
| Jun 16, 2025 | Listed for rent | $2,265 | Rently |
| May 12, 2022 | Sold | $249,900 | Public Record |
| May 6, 2022 | Sold | $249,900 | IRMLS |
| Apr 12, 2022 | Listed | $239,000 | MLS #97477 |
| Jul 26, 2001 | Sold | $112,611 | Public Record |
Tax assessment history
| Year | Building | Land | Total assessed | Tax paid |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2025 | $198,200 | $42,400 | $240,600 | $5,466 |
| 2024 | $181,700 | $42,400 | $224,100 | $5,128 |
| 2023 | $137,800 | $42,400 | $180,200 | $3,710 |
| 2022 | $138,900 | $22,500 | $161,400 | $1,911 |
| 2021 | $138,900 | $22,500 | $161,400 | $1,715 |
| 2020 | $122,600 | $22,500 | $145,100 | $1,550 |
| 2019 | $115,900 | $22,500 | $138,400 | $1,480 |
| 2018 | $104,400 | $22,500 | $126,900 | $1,356 |
| 2017 | $98,600 | $22,500 | $121,100 | $1,255 |
| 2016 | $96,300 | $22,500 | $118,800 | $1,218 |
| 2015 | $97,700 | $22,500 | $120,200 | $1,150 |
| 2014 | $90,100 | $22,500 | $112,600 | $1,032 |
| 2013 | $87,200 | $22,500 | $109,700 | $989 |
| 2012 | $87,100 | $22,500 | $109,600 | $901 |
| 2011 | $79,700 | $27,200 | $106,900 | $764 |
| 2010 | $79,700 | $27,200 | $106,900 | $681 |
| 2008 | $91,000 | $27,200 | $118,200 | $928 |
| 2006 | $91,900 | $27,600 | $119,500 | $1,330 |
Property facts
Year built
1996
Property type
single_family
Stories
1
Beds
3
Baths
2
Living area
1,499 sqft
Lot size
14,793 sqft
ZIP code
46254
City
Indianapolis
Street
Pillory Way
Coordinates
39.86627, -86.26268
Comparable properties nearby
Investment analysis
Estimates based on local averages — not personalized adviceEstimated monthly rent
$2,249
Gross rental yield
10.80%
Implied cap rate
7.02%
Trend-extrapolated value
—
Frequently asked questions
When did 5735 Pillory Way last sell?
5735 Pillory Way most recently sold on May 12, 2022 for $249,900.
What is the current tax assessment for 5735 Pillory Way?
The most recent total assessment for 5735 Pillory Way (year 2025) is $240,600 with $5,466 in property tax.
How does 5735 Pillory Way's assessment compare to its last sale price?
The current assessment is 3.7% below the last sale price of $249,900.
When was 5735 Pillory Way built?
5735 Pillory Way was built in 1996.
How does 5735 Pillory Way compare to others on Pillory Way?
We track 3 other properties on Pillory Way. Browse the list under "Other properties on Pillory Way" to compare beds, baths, and sale history.
What are the property facts for 5735 Pillory Way?
5735 Pillory Way is a 3 bed, 2 bath, 1,499 sqft, 14,793 sqft lot single_family.
Is 5735 Pillory Way a flip candidate?
No — 5735 Pillory Way does not appear in our flips dataset.
Is 5735 Pillory Way a tax-appeal candidate?
No — 5735 Pillory Way is not currently flagged as a tax-appeal candidate.
Forecast for this area
ZIP-area linear projection — not a per-property automated valuationQuarterly trend
-4.3%
Implied 1-yr
-17.1%
2026 Q3
$181.9K
2026 Q4
$181.9K
ZIP 46254 — Median Price History + Forecast
Explore nearby
Geography
Other properties on Pillory Way