12 New York Ave

Oak Bluffs, MA 02557

4 bd 3 ba 1,828 sqft Built 1870 Lot 5,663 sqft single_family

Most recent sale

$596,000

Sep 28, 2022

Location

Timeline: Sale, Listing & Tax History

Recorded events

Date	Event	Price	Source
Dec 29, 2022	Sold	$1,650,000	MarthasVineyardMLS
Oct 21, 2022	Price changed	$1,850,000	MLS #32200192
Oct 13, 2022	Relisted	$1,290,000	MLS #39687
Oct 12, 2022	Listed	$1,349,000	MLS #32200352
Oct 11, 2022	Price changed	$1,650,000	MLS #32200291
Oct 6, 2022	Price changed	$1,395,000	MLS #32200289
Oct 5, 2022	Listed	$1,495,000	MLS #32200344
Sep 28, 2022	Listed	$1,795,000	MLS #32200325
Sep 28, 2022	Sold	$596,000	MLS #32200236
Sep 26, 2022	Listed	$1,950,000	MLS #32200315
Sep 21, 2022	Price changed	$1,495,000	MLS #40003
Sep 20, 2022	Sold	$780,000	MLS #32200170
Sep 20, 2022	Price changed	$9,750,000	MLS #32200172
Sep 20, 2022	Listed	$1,999,000	MLS #32200316
Sep 19, 2022	Listed	$1,950,000	MLS #40103
Sep 13, 2022	Listed	$1,899,000	MLS #32200294
Sep 9, 2022	Sold	$3,500,000	MLS #32200233
Sep 8, 2022	Listed	$1,899,000	MLS #39754
Sep 3, 2022	Listed	$1,595,000	MLS #32200289
Sep 3, 2022	Listed	$1,699,000	MLS #32200291
Sep 1, 2022	Listed	$1,595,000	MLS #40003
Aug 13, 2022	Price changed	$2,195,000	MLS #32200206
Aug 2, 2022	Listed	$1,850,000	MLS #32200238
Jul 31, 2022	Price changed	$1,290,000	MLS #32200171
Jul 31, 2022	Price changed	$1,290,000	MLS #32200171
Jul 29, 2022	Listed	$2,700,000	MLS #32200233
Jul 29, 2022	Price changed	$1,290,000	MLS #39687
Jul 29, 2022	Listed	$589,000	MLS #32200236
Jul 29, 2022	Price changed	$1,290,000	MLS #39687
Jul 27, 2022	Sold	$1,000,000	MLS #32200120
Jul 15, 2022	Price changed	$1,099,000	MLS #39572
Jul 11, 2022	Price changed	$749,000	MLS #39663
Jul 1, 2022	Relisted	$1,399,999	MLS #32200171
Jul 1, 2022	Relisted	$1,399,999	MLS #22202868
Jul 1, 2022	Listed	$2,349,000	MLS #32200206
Jun 30, 2022	Relisted	$1,399,999	MLS #39687
Jun 30, 2022	Relisted	$1,399,999	MLS #39687
Jun 18, 2022	Price changed	$1,399,999	MLS #32200171
Jun 18, 2022	Price changed	$1,399,999	MLS #22202868
Jun 15, 2022	Listed	$849,000	MLS #32200195
Jun 14, 2022	Listed	$1,925,000	MLS #32200192
Jun 14, 2022	Price changed	$1,399,999	MLS #39687
Jun 14, 2022	Price changed	$1,399,999	MLS #39687
Jun 10, 2022	Sold	$1,800,000	MLS #32200023
Jun 8, 2022	Listed	$1,425,000	MLS #22202868
Jun 3, 2022	Listed	$12,000,000	MLS #32200172
Jun 3, 2022	Listed	$1,425,000	MLS #32200171
Jun 3, 2022	Listed	$1,425,000	MLS #32200171
Jun 2, 2022	Listed	$1,425,000	MLS #39687
Jun 2, 2022	Listed	$1,425,000	MLS #39687
Jun 2, 2022	Listed	$800,000	MLS #32200170
May 23, 2022	Listed	$1,299,000	MLS #32200151
May 18, 2022	Listed	$1,299,000	MLS #39572
May 5, 2022	Listed	$1,290,000	MLS #39533
Mar 22, 2022	Price changed	$2,250,000	MLS #38062
Feb 18, 2022	Listed	$2,750,000	MLS #39276
Feb 3, 2022	Listed	$2,750,000	MLS #32200026
Feb 1, 2022	Listed	$2,500,000	MLS #38062
Nov 6, 2020	Sold	$1,051,000	MLS #32000533
Oct 14, 2016	Sold	$815,000	MLS #21603153
Aug 11, 2016	Price changed	$850,000	MLS #21603153
Apr 22, 2016	Listed	$875,000	MLS #21603153
Apr 21, 2016	Listed	$850,000	MLS #21603153
Jan 24, 2015	Listed	$829,000	MLS #21500604
Aug 10, 2007	Sold	$250,000	Public Record
Aug 11, 2006	Sold	$505,000	Public Record
Jun 9, 2006	Sold	$590,000	Public Record
Oct 28, 2004	Sold	$217,500	Public Record
Jun 22, 1999	Sold	$301,000	Public Record
Jun 1, 1998	Sold	$280,000	Public Record

Tax assessment history

Year	Building	Land	Total assessed	Tax paid
2024	$496,700	$1,098,000	$1,594,700	$8,340
2023	$482,600	$1,066,900	$1,549,500	—
2022	$363,900	$800,500	$1,164,400	—
2022	—	$240,900	$240,900	$1,636
2022	$324,800	$542,900	$867,700	$5,892
2022	$442,800	$425,000	$867,800	$5,892
2022	$662,000	$369,000	$1,031,000	$7,000
2022	$443,400	$785,500	$1,228,900	$8,344
2022	$408,100	$401,500	$809,600	$5,497
2022	$237,100	$314,300	$551,400	$3,744
2022	$497,700	$408,900	$906,600	$6,156
2022	$429,200	$815,200	$1,244,400	$8,449
2022	$326,400	$617,400	$943,800	$6,408
2022	$361,400	$595,400	$956,800	—
2022	$631,500	$425,800	$1,057,300	$7,179
2022	$238,500	$401,500	$640,000	$4,346
2022	$598,800	—	$598,800	$4,066
2022	—	$385,400	$385,400	$2,617
2022	$1,137,500	$650,400	$1,787,900	$12,140
2021	$315,000	$680,300	$995,300	—
2021	—	$207,100	$207,100	$1,526
2021	$294,000	$386,500	$680,500	$5,015
2021	$407,300	$357,400	$764,700	$5,636
2021	$592,400	$348,800	$941,200	$6,937
2021	$403,600	$690,200	$1,093,800	$8,061
2021	$353,300	$301,100	$654,400	$4,823
2021	$200,700	$284,400	$485,100	$3,575
2021	$421,700	$308,200	$729,900	$5,379
2021	$347,400	$712,700	$1,060,100	$7,813
2021	$291,500	$727,000	$1,018,500	$7,506
2021	$354,200	$555,900	$910,100	$6,707
2021	$610,400	$418,200	$1,028,600	$7,581
2021	$195,600	$301,000	$496,600	$3,660
2021	$515,600	—	$515,600	$3,800
2021	—	$366,000	$366,000	$2,697
2021	$948,300	$505,100	$1,453,400	$10,712
2020	$291,000	$647,900	$938,900	—
2020	—	$184,100	$184,100	$1,370
2020	$272,200	$368,100	$640,300	$4,764
2020	$376,900	$340,400	$717,300	$5,337
2020	$552,200	$332,200	$884,400	$6,580
2020	$376,900	$657,400	$1,034,300	$7,695
2020	$327,700	$286,800	$614,500	$4,572
2020	$185,800	$270,900	$456,700	$3,398
2020	$391,600	$293,500	$685,100	$5,097
2020	$322,300	$678,700	$1,001,000	$7,447
2020	$276,000	$692,400	$968,400	$7,205
2020	$338,200	$529,400	$867,600	$6,455
2020	$572,100	$398,300	$970,400	$7,220
2020	$182,000	$286,700	$468,700	$3,487
2020	$477,300	—	$477,300	$3,551
2020	—	$348,600	$348,600	$2,594
2020	$878,700	$481,100	$1,359,800	$10,117
2019	$284,400	$626,100	$910,500	—
2019	—	$160,600	$160,600	$1,235
2019	$266,700	$354,800	$621,500	$4,779
2019	$369,400	$311,500	$680,900	$5,236
2019	$505,000	$320,500	$825,500	$6,348
2019	$370,300	$604,100	$974,400	$7,493
2019	$320,400	$263,800	$584,200	$4,492
2019	$182,500	$261,300	$443,800	$3,413
2019	$384,200	$270,000	$654,200	$5,031
2019	$316,300	$656,600	$972,900	$7,482
2019	$269,500	$661,000	$930,500	$7,156
2019	$338,200	$484,800	$823,000	$6,329
2019	$562,400	$366,000	$928,400	$7,139
2019	$178,600	$263,800	$442,400	$3,402
2019	$417,600	—	$417,600	$3,211
2019	—	$336,200	$336,200	$2,585
2019	$862,800	$459,900	$1,322,700	$10,172
2018	$284,400	$541,900	$826,300	—
2018	—	$145,000	$145,000	$1,135
2018	$266,500	$333,900	$600,400	$4,701
2018	$369,400	$273,800	$643,200	$5,036
2018	$506,500	$277,800	$784,300	$6,141
2018	$374,900	$545,500	$920,400	$7,207
2018	$207,000	$207,200	$414,200	$3,243
2018	$184,000	$226,600	$410,600	$3,215
2018	$384,200	$222,700	$606,900	$4,752
2018	$315,600	$617,600	$933,200	$7,307
2018	$269,000	$654,500	$923,500	$7,231
2018	$324,800	$404,900	$729,700	$5,714
2018	$555,900	$342,500	$898,400	$7,034
2018	$177,500	$207,200	$384,700	$3,012
2018	$417,600	—	$417,600	$3,270
2018	—	$291,300	$291,300	$2,281
2018	$870,600	$454,200	$1,324,800	$10,373
2017	$252,500	$504,300	$756,800	—
2017	$238,300	$361,700	$600,000	$4,890
2017	$329,600	$268,500	$598,100	$4,875
2017	$420,600	$263,400	$684,000	$5,575
2017	$331,000	$506,100	$837,100	$6,822
2017	$185,500	$196,400	$381,900	$3,112
2017	$145,500	$214,800	$360,300	$2,936
2017	$335,900	$211,100	$547,000	$4,458
2017	$281,300	$659,900	$941,200	$7,671
2017	$246,400	$629,800	$876,200	$7,141
2017	$320,300	$384,300	$704,600	$5,742
2017	$488,400	$324,700	$813,100	$6,627
2017	$157,800	$196,400	$354,200	$2,887
2017	$425,300	—	$425,300	$3,466
2017	—	$276,200	$276,200	$2,251
2017	$770,500	$442,200	$1,212,700	$9,884
2016	$219,000	$519,900	$738,900	—
2016	$212,500	$354,300	$566,800	$4,597
2016	$294,800	$276,800	$571,600	$4,636
2016	$349,800	$271,500	$621,300	$5,039
2016	$255,500	$521,800	$777,300	$6,304
2016	$158,700	$202,500	$361,200	$2,929
2016	$136,700	$221,400	$358,100	$2,904
2016	$268,800	$217,600	$486,400	$3,945
2016	$244,600	$680,300	$924,900	$7,501
2016	$222,000	$649,300	$871,300	$7,066
2016	$293,000	$373,700	$666,700	$5,407
2016	$393,500	$334,800	$728,300	$5,907
2016	$129,600	$202,500	$332,100	$2,693
2016	$409,400	—	$409,400	$3,320
2016	—	$284,700	$284,700	$2,309
2016	$655,000	$455,900	$1,110,900	$9,009
2015	$203,100	$519,900	$723,000	—
2015	$192,800	$372,900	$565,700	$4,503
2015	$268,300	$276,800	$545,100	$4,339
2015	$323,600	$272,500	$596,100	$4,745
2015	$235,600	$521,800	$757,400	$6,029
2015	$146,900	$202,500	$349,400	$2,781
2015	$127,000	$221,400	$348,400	$2,773
2015	$227,600	$217,600	$445,200	$3,544
2015	$227,100	$680,300	$907,400	$7,223
2015	$211,500	$649,300	$860,800	$6,852
2015	$290,600	$373,700	$664,300	$5,288
2015	$364,200	$310,900	$675,100	$5,374
2015	$119,300	$202,500	$321,800	$2,562
2015	$364,500	—	$364,500	$2,901
2015	—	$284,700	$284,700	$2,266
2015	$604,900	$455,900	$1,060,800	$8,444
2014	$235,500	$358,500	$594,000	$4,639
2014	$315,700	$281,800	$597,500	$4,666
2014	$326,500	$259,700	$586,200	$4,578
2014	$249,500	$507,100	$756,600	$5,909
2014	$151,800	$187,100	$338,900	$2,647
2014	$131,700	$209,100	$340,800	$2,662
2014	$242,600	$210,000	$452,600	$3,535
2014	$222,100	$638,100	$860,200	$6,718
2014	$214,900	$847,400	$1,062,300	$8,297
2014	$278,100	$377,900	$656,000	$5,123
2014	$378,400	$311,800	$690,200	$5,390
2014	$122,600	$187,100	$309,700	$2,419
2014	$359,300	—	$359,300	$2,806
2014	—	$273,600	$273,600	$2,137
2014	$608,600	$457,200	$1,065,800	$8,324
2006	$151,900	$260,800	$412,700	$2,373
2006	$235,300	$335,300	$570,600	$3,281
2006	$389,400	$282,000	$671,400	$3,861
2006	$289,200	$510,100	$799,300	$4,596
2006	$172,300	$242,400	$414,700	$2,385
2006	$133,300	$193,400	$326,700	$1,879
2006	—	$263,600	$263,600	$1,516
2006	$198,200	$518,000	$716,200	$4,118
2006	$201,400	$785,100	$986,500	$5,672
2006	$158,100	$356,300	$514,400	$2,958
2006	$449,500	$307,300	$756,800	$4,352
2006	$164,600	$242,500	$407,100	$2,341
2006	$326,000	—	$326,000	$1,875
2006	—	$293,300	$293,300	$1,686
2006	—	$402,600	$402,600	$2,315
2005	$153,100	$266,000	$419,100	$2,544
2005	$233,200	$273,300	$506,500	$3,074
2005	$408,800	$222,700	$631,500	$3,833
2005	$315,100	$439,800	$754,900	$4,582
2005	$165,700	$161,600	$327,300	$1,987
2005	$125,900	$128,900	$254,800	$1,547
2005	—	$189,900	$189,900	$1,153
2005	$199,300	$528,000	$727,300	$4,415
2005	$202,600	$800,700	$1,003,300	$6,090
2005	$158,100	$287,400	$445,500	$2,704
2005	$489,400	$270,900	$760,300	$4,615
2005	$180,100	$161,700	$341,800	$2,075
2005	$283,600	—	$283,600	$1,721
2005	—	$236,900	$236,900	$1,438
2005	—	$419,400	$419,400	$2,546
2004	$138,700	$210,700	$349,400	$2,386
2004	$211,300	$221,800	$433,100	$2,958
2004	$333,000	$168,900	$501,900	$3,428
2004	$243,600	$445,700	$689,300	$4,708
2004	$149,200	$140,600	$289,800	$1,979
2004	$113,700	$100,800	$214,500	$1,465
2004	—	$157,100	$157,100	$1,073
2004	$160,100	$290,400	$450,500	$3,077
2004	$180,800	$731,300	$912,100	$6,230
2004	$255,500	$127,200	$382,700	$2,614
2004	$445,300	$255,600	$700,900	$4,787
2004	$166,600	$140,700	$307,300	$2,099
2004	$224,900	—	$224,900	$1,536
2004	—	$211,000	$211,000	$1,441
2004	—	$351,100	$351,100	$2,398
2003	$123,300	$183,100	$306,400	$2,139
2003	$189,300	$136,500	$325,800	$2,274
2003	$306,500	$187,700	$494,200	$3,450
2003	$210,100	$387,500	$597,600	$4,171
2003	$118,200	$122,400	$240,600	$1,679
2003	$99,400	$87,500	$186,900	$1,305
2003	—	$123,400	$123,400	$861
2003	$139,200	$252,500	$391,700	$2,734
2003	$117,700	$742,200	$859,900	$6,002
2003	$218,900	$110,600	$329,500	$2,300
2003	$344,000	$223,200	$567,200	$3,959
2003	$145,500	$122,200	$267,700	$1,869
2003	$165,500	—	$165,500	$1,155
2003	—	$19,000	$19,000	$133
2003	—	$306,100	$306,100	$2,137

Property facts

Year built

1870

Property type

single_family

Stories

Beds

Baths

Living area

1,828 sqft

Lot size

5,663 sqft

ZIP code

02557

City

Oak Bluffs

Street

New York Ave

Coordinates

41.45816, -70.56378

Comparable properties nearby

Investment analysis

Estimates based on local averages — not personalized advice

Estimated monthly rent

$5,301

Gross rental yield

10.67%

Implied cap rate

6.94%

Trend-extrapolated value

—

Frequently asked questions

When did 12 New York Ave last sell?

12 New York Ave most recently sold on Sep 28, 2022 for $596,000.

What is the current tax assessment for 12 New York Ave?

The most recent total assessment for 12 New York Ave (year 2024) is $1,594,700 with $8,340 in property tax.

How does 12 New York Ave's assessment compare to its last sale price?

The current assessment is 167.6% above the last sale price of $596,000.

When was 12 New York Ave built?

12 New York Ave was built in 1870.

How does 12 New York Ave compare to others on New York Ave?

We track 8 other properties on New York Ave. Browse the list under "Other properties on New York Ave" to compare beds, baths, and sale history.

What are the property facts for 12 New York Ave?

12 New York Ave is a 4 bed, 3 bath, 1,828 sqft, 5,663 sqft lot single_family.

Is 12 New York Ave a flip candidate?

Yes — 12 New York Ave appears in our flips dataset, indicating it sold twice within a short window with a notable price change.

Is 12 New York Ave a tax-appeal candidate?

No — 12 New York Ave is not currently flagged as a tax-appeal candidate.

Forecast for this area

ZIP-area linear projection — not a per-property automated valuation

Quarterly trend

+0.6%

Implied 1-yr

+2.3%

2026 Q2

$1.5M

2026 Q3

$1.51M

ZIP 02557 — Median Price History + Forecast

Linear regression on last 12 quarters of weighted-median sale price. Confidence band ±$596.9K. This is a ZIP-area forecast used as a neighborhood proxy — not a per-property automated valuation.

Explore nearby

Geography

Other properties on New York Ave