Shelter Island, NY
City market trends and history
Public Record
Median Sale Price
$2.2M
12-Month Sales
17
+51.1%
1-Year Appreciation
+51.1%
Properties Tracked
854
Median Sale Price History
Top Neighborhoods
| Name | Median |
|---|
Top Neighborhoods by Activity
No neighborhood data available
Neighborhood-level stats are available for ~24k of the ~215k U.S. neighborhoods — Shelter Island is not currently covered.
Top ZIP Codes
Recent Sales
| Date | Address | Price |
|---|---|---|
| Apr 20, 2026 | S Ferry Rd | $3.5M |
| Jan 27, 2026 | 179 RAM ISLAND DR | $5.6M |
| Jan 14, 2026 | Country Club Dr | $1.73M |
| Oct 16, 2025 | Gazon Rd | $2.65M |
| Oct 14, 2025 | 179 RAM ISLAND DR | $5.6M |
| Oct 14, 2025 | Shorewood Rd | $120K |
| Sep 4, 2025 | Dinah Rock Rd | $2M |
| Aug 20, 2025 | 8 TIMS TRL | $1.75M |
| Aug 20, 2025 | W Neck Rd | $799K |
| Jul 17, 2025 | Nostrand Pkwy | $3.65M |
| Jul 2, 2025 | W Neck Rd | $799K |
| May 28, 2025 | Nostrand Pkwy | $3.65M |
| Mar 31, 2025 | Sea Gull Rd | $1.95M |
| Feb 11, 2025 | St Marys Rd | $3.5M |
| Jan 14, 2025 | Mimosa Pl | $1.4M |
| Jan 2, 2025 | Dering Woods Rd | $895K |
| Nov 30, 2024 | 70 S FERRY RD | $798K |
| Nov 22, 2024 | Dering Woods Rd | $895K |
| Nov 21, 2024 | Great Circle Rd | $1.58M |
| Nov 15, 2024 | St Marys Rd | $3.5M |
4-Quarter Forecast
Linear projection from past trendQuarterly trend
+7.0%
Implied 1-yr
+27.9%
2026 Q3
$3.17M
2026 Q4
$3.32M
Median Price — History + Forecast
Property type mix
Share by property type
Year-built distribution
Properties by build era
Map
Recent top sales — most expensive
| Address | Sale date | Sale price |
|---|---|---|
| 2 CHARLIES LN | Sep 6, 2023 | $12,950,000 |
| 149 RAM ISLAND DR | Aug 9, 2022 | $9,700,000 |
| N Ram Island Dr | Aug 9, 2022 | $9,700,000 |
| Ram Island Rd | Dec 7, 2022 | $5,750,000 |
| Shorewood Rd | Nov 16, 2021 | $5,250,000 |
| Montclair Ln | Jan 3, 2022 | $4,900,000 |
| Peconic Ave | Mar 18, 2022 | $4,900,000 |
| Margarets Dr | Feb 28, 2022 | $4,500,000 |
| Margarets Dr | Jan 11, 2022 | $4,500,000 |
| Club Dr | Nov 23, 2022 | $4,050,000 |
How Shelter Island compares
| Metric | Shelter Island | New York avg | US avg |
|---|---|---|---|
| Median price | $2.2M | $882.3K | $535.4K |
| 1-year change | +51.1% | -9.3% | -5.4% |
| Sales (12mo) | 17 | 12,296 | — |
| Median sqft | — | — | — |
Other cities in New York
How Shelter Island ranks in New York
1-year appreciation
#131 of 1645
Median price
#13 of 1645
Frequently asked about Shelter Island
What is the median sale price in Shelter Island, NY?
The median sale price in Shelter Island over the last 12 months is $2.2M, based on 17 transactions.
How fast are home prices appreciating in Shelter Island?
Shelter Island home prices have changed +51.1% year-over-year on a median basis.
How many sales happen each year in Shelter Island?
Roughly 17 home sales were recorded in Shelter Island over the trailing 12 months.
What types of properties are most common in Shelter Island?
single_family is the most common property type tracked in Shelter Island.
When were most homes in Shelter Island built?
Most homes in Shelter Island were built in the Pre-1950 era.