ZIP 11954
ZIP-level market data for Montauk, NY
Public Record
Median Sale Price
$2.81M
12-Month Sales
18
1-Year Appreciation
—
Properties Tracked
191
Median Sale Price History
Top Streets
| Street | Properties |
|---|---|
| Old Montauk Hwy | 13 |
| Surfside Ave | 10 |
| Edgemere St | 8 |
| Lake Dr | 8 |
| Fairview Ave | 8 |
| Ranch Ct | 5 |
| Old West Lake Dr | 4 |
| Tara Rd | 4 |
| Deforest Rd | 4 |
| Fort Pond Rd | 4 |
| Cleveland Dr | 4 |
| Benson Dr | 4 |
| Flamingo Ave | 3 |
| Essex St | 3 |
| Second House Rd | 3 |
| Gilbert Rd | 3 |
| Tuthill Rd | 3 |
| Montauk Hwy | 3 |
| Freemont Rd | 2 |
| Fir Ln | 2 |
Streets in ZIP 11954
| Street | Properties |
|---|---|
| Old Montauk Hwy | 13 |
| Surfside Ave | 10 |
| Edgemere St | 8 |
| Lake Dr | 8 |
| Fairview Ave | 8 |
| Ranch Ct | 5 |
| Old West Lake Dr | 4 |
| Tara Rd | 4 |
| Deforest Rd | 4 |
| Fort Pond Rd | 4 |
| Cleveland Dr | 4 |
| Benson Dr | 4 |
| Flamingo Ave | 3 |
| Essex St | 3 |
| Second House Rd | 3 |
| Gilbert Rd | 3 |
| Tuthill Rd | 3 |
| Montauk Hwy | 3 |
| Freemont Rd | 2 |
| Fir Ln | 2 |
Recent Sales
| Date | Address | City | Price |
|---|---|---|---|
| Jan 27, 2026 | 140 NAVY RD | Montauk | $4.4M |
| Jan 13, 2026 | 35 BENSON DR | Montauk | $3.2M |
| Jan 8, 2026 | 1 N SURFSIDE AVE | Montauk | $4.18M |
| Dec 15, 2025 | 225 OLD MONTAUK HWY | Montauk | $10.5M |
| Dec 5, 2025 | 140 NAVY RD | Montauk | $4.4M |
| Nov 28, 2025 | 65 SECOND HOUSE RD | Montauk | $2.75M |
| Nov 25, 2025 | 14 FREEMONT RD | Montauk | $1.9M |
| Oct 10, 2025 | 123 FAIRVIEW AVE | Montauk | $1.85M |
| May 8, 2025 | 717 MONTAUK HWY | Montauk | $1M |
| Mar 26, 2025 | 50 GLOUCESTER AVE | Montauk | $1.75M |
| Mar 20, 2025 | 41 GILBERT RD | Montauk | $1.8M |
| Feb 20, 2025 | 50 GLOUCESTER AVE | Montauk | $1.75M |
| Feb 14, 2025 | 3 LEON CT | Montauk | $6.1M |
| Jan 29, 2025 | 23 OLD WEST LAKE DR | Montauk | $2.43M |
| Jan 27, 2025 | 236 EDGEMERE ST UNIT 428 | Montauk | $408.5K |
| Dec 27, 2024 | 17 TARA RD | Montauk | $5M |
| Dec 17, 2024 | 3 LEON CT | Montauk | $6.1M |
| Dec 13, 2024 | 23 OLD WEST LAKE DR | Montauk | $2.43M |
| Dec 9, 2024 | 97 OLD WEST LAKE DR | Montauk | $2.2M |
| Nov 19, 2024 | 17 TARA RD | Montauk | $5M |
4-Quarter Forecast
Linear projection from past trendQuarterly trend
-1.1%
Implied 1-yr
-4.4%
2026 Q1
$3.21M
2026 Q2
$3.21M
Median Price — History + Forecast
Property type mix
Share by property type
Year-built distribution
Properties by build era
Map
Recent top sales — most expensive
| Address | City | Sale date | Sale price |
|---|---|---|---|
| 42 OLD MONTAUK HWY | Montauk | Oct 21, 2022 | $25,000,000 |
| 42 OLD MONTAUK HWY | Montauk | Mar 12, 2024 | $18,500,000 |
| 42 OLD MONTAUK HWY | Montauk | Dec 22, 2023 | $18,500,000 |
| 66 SURFSIDE AVE | Montauk | Oct 27, 2022 | $17,500,000 |
| 66 SURFSIDE AVE | Montauk | Aug 26, 2022 | $17,350,000 |
| 216 OLD MONTAUK HWY | Montauk | May 4, 2023 | $14,000,000 |
| 14 MAPLE ST | Montauk | Dec 14, 2022 | $13,900,000 |
| 8 WASHINGTON DR | Montauk | Jun 15, 2022 | $8,500,000 |
| 36 HOMEWARD LN | Montauk | Jul 21, 2023 | $8,348,000 |
| 63 HOUSTON DR | Montauk | May 2, 2022 | $8,150,000 |
Nearby ZIP codes
How ZIP 11954 ranks in New York
1-year appreciation
#945 of 1641
Median price
#983 of 1641
Frequently asked about ZIP 11954
What is the median sale price in ZIP 11954?
The median sale price in ZIP 11954 over the last 12 months is $2.81M, based on 18 transactions.
How many sales happen each year in ZIP 11954?
Roughly 18 home sales were recorded in ZIP 11954 over the trailing 12 months.
What types of properties are most common in ZIP 11954?
Unknown is the most common property type tracked in ZIP 11954.
When were most homes in ZIP 11954 built?
Most homes in ZIP 11954 were built in the 1980-1989 era.