Skip to main content
MarketTimeline.com
MT
MarketTimeline
.com
Methodology Top Markets
Public Record 42M+ events · 6.2M properties All 50 states Data through July 2024 Methodology

ZIP 15438

ZIP-level market data for Fayette City, PA

Public Record
Median Sale Price
$194.2K
12-Month Sales
12
1-Year Appreciation
Properties Tracked
264
Median Sale Price History
Top Streets
StreetProperties
Newell Rd 21
Connellsville Rd 20
Brownsville Rd 18
Gillespie Rd 13
Fayette City Rd 12
Connellsville St 12
Naomi Rd 10
Washington Dr 10
2nd St 9
Main St 8
Cook St 8
3rd St 8
Jefferson Dr 8
Navaho Hollow Rd 8
Lowber Rd 7
Liberty St 6
Gilliespie Hollow Rd 5
High St 5
4th St 5
Market St 5

Streets in ZIP 15438

Street Properties
Newell Rd 21
Connellsville Rd 20
Brownsville Rd 18
Gillespie Rd 13
Fayette City Rd 12
Connellsville St 12
Naomi Rd 10
Washington Dr 10
2nd St 9
Main St 8
Cook St 8
3rd St 8
Jefferson Dr 8
Navaho Hollow Rd 8
Lowber Rd 7
Liberty St 6
Gilliespie Hollow Rd 5
High St 5
4th St 5
Market St 5

Recent Sales

Date Address City Price
Oct 7, 2025 2nd St Fayette City $98K
Oct 8, 2024 Williams Rd Fayette City $122K
Sep 19, 2024 HARDING DR LOT 62 Fayette City $12K
May 13, 2024 149 CONNELLSVILLE ST Fayette City $58K
Feb 2, 2023 Naomi Rd Fayette City $70K
Jan 23, 2023 Connellsville St Fayette City $210K
Jan 5, 2023 Brownsville Rd Fayette City $189.9K
Nov 22, 2022 Main St Fayette City $28K
Nov 10, 2022 Cook St Fayette City $33K
Oct 31, 2022 Fayette Ave Fayette City $47K
Oct 28, 2022 Gilliespie Hollow Rd Fayette City $20K
Oct 28, 2022 Cook St Fayette City $33K
Oct 21, 2022 Naomi Rd Fayette City $153K
Sep 7, 2022 Elwell St Fayette City $99K
Aug 12, 2022 Liberty St Fayette City $125K
Jun 2, 2022 Center St Fayette City $55K
May 20, 2022 Fayette St Fayette City $94.5K
May 16, 2022 Redstone Church Rd Fayette City $735K
May 4, 2022 Redstone Church Rd Fayette City $735K
Apr 14, 2022 Connellsville St Fayette City $210K

4-Quarter Forecast

Linear projection from past trend
Quarterly trend
+8.2%
Implied 1-yr
+32.7%
2022 Q4
$225.3K
2023 Q1
$237.3K
Median Price — History + Forecast

Property type mix

Share by property type

Year-built distribution

Properties by build era

Tax burden snapshot

Avg effective rate
2.9593%
Avg annual tax
$2.3K
Avg assessment
$77.4K

Map

Recent top sales — most expensive

AddressCitySale dateSale price
Redstone Church Rd Fayette City May 4, 2022 $735,000
Redstone Church Rd Fayette City May 16, 2022 $735,000
Curcio Dr Fayette City Nov 15, 2021 $299,900
Connellsville St Fayette City Jan 23, 2023 $210,000
Connellsville St Fayette City Apr 14, 2022 $209,999
Brownsville Rd Fayette City Jan 5, 2023 $189,900
Connellsville Rd Fayette City Nov 12, 2021 $180,000
Naomi Rd Fayette City Oct 21, 2022 $153,000
Newell Rd Fayette City Feb 28, 2022 $135,000
Connellsville St Fayette City Nov 24, 2021 $127,500

Nearby ZIP codes

How ZIP 15438 ranks in Pennsylvania

1-year appreciation
#171 of 1346
Median price
#794 of 1346

Frequently asked about ZIP 15438

What is the median sale price in ZIP 15438?
The median sale price in ZIP 15438 over the last 12 months is $194.2K, based on 12 transactions.
How many sales happen each year in ZIP 15438?
Roughly 12 home sales were recorded in ZIP 15438 over the trailing 12 months.
What types of properties are most common in ZIP 15438?
single_family is the most common property type tracked in ZIP 15438.
What's the effective property tax rate in ZIP 15438?
The average effective property tax rate in ZIP 15438 is approximately 2.9593%.
When were most homes in ZIP 15438 built?
Most homes in ZIP 15438 were built in the Pre-1950 era.