5 Gardiners Bay Dr
Shelter Island, NY 11964
3 bd 3 ba 2,577 sqft Built 1970 Lot 82,764 sqft single_family
Most recent sale
$1,751,000
Oct 24, 2022
Location
Timeline: Sale, Listing & Tax History
Recorded events
| Date | Event | Price | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Dec 2, 2022 | Sold | $1,751,000 | Public Record |
| Oct 24, 2022 | Sold | $1,751,000 | MLS #11096383 |
| Jul 29, 2022 | Listed | $1,295,000 | MLS #11096383 |
Tax assessment history
| Year | Building | Land | Total assessed | Tax paid |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2025 | $477,000 | $907,000 | $1,384,000 | $9,659 |
| 2024 | $477,000 | $907,000 | $1,384,000 | $9,171 |
| 2023 | $477,000 | $907,000 | $1,384,000 | $4,412 |
| 2022 | $477,000 | $907,000 | $1,384,000 | $8,711 |
| 2021 | $463,000 | $907,000 | $1,370,000 | $8,498 |
| 2020 | $460,000 | $907,000 | $1,367,000 | $8,338 |
| 2017 | $432,500 | $892,500 | $1,325,000 | $7,899 |
| 2016 | $414,600 | $885,400 | $1,300,000 | $7,919 |
| 2015 | $401,200 | $856,800 | $1,258,000 | $7,639 |
| 2014 | $357,000 | $833,000 | $1,190,000 | $7,380 |
| 2013 | $338,900 | $821,100 | $1,160,000 | $7,183 |
| 2012 | $316,000 | $833,000 | $1,149,000 | $6,941 |
| 2011 | $254,000 | $952,000 | $1,206,000 | $6,907 |
| 2010 | $243,000 | $952,000 | $1,195,000 | $6,791 |
| 2008 | $316,800 | $1,023,400 | $1,340,200 | $6,785 |
| 2007 | $258,400 | $952,000 | $1,210,400 | $6,181 |
| 2006 | $285,700 | $833,000 | $1,118,700 | $6,223 |
Property facts
Year built
1970
Property type
single_family
Stories
—
Beds
3
Baths
3
Living area
2,577 sqft
Lot size
82,764 sqft
ZIP code
11964
City
Shelter Island
Street
Gardiners Bay Dr
Coordinates
41.09256, -72.32479
Comparable properties nearby
Investment analysis
Estimates based on local averages — not personalized adviceEstimated monthly rent
$8,762
Gross rental yield
6.00%
Implied cap rate
3.90%
Trend-extrapolated value
—
Frequently asked questions
When did 5 Gardiners Bay Dr last sell?
5 Gardiners Bay Dr most recently sold on Oct 24, 2022 for $1,751,000.
What is the current tax assessment for 5 Gardiners Bay Dr?
The most recent total assessment for 5 Gardiners Bay Dr (year 2025) is $1,384,000 with $9,659 in property tax.
How does 5 Gardiners Bay Dr's assessment compare to its last sale price?
The current assessment is 21.0% below the last sale price of $1,751,000.
When was 5 Gardiners Bay Dr built?
5 Gardiners Bay Dr was built in 1970.
How does 5 Gardiners Bay Dr compare to others on Gardiners Bay Dr?
We track 8 other properties on Gardiners Bay Dr. Browse the list under "Other properties on Gardiners Bay Dr" to compare beds, baths, and sale history.
What are the property facts for 5 Gardiners Bay Dr?
5 Gardiners Bay Dr is a 3 bed, 3 bath, 2,577 sqft, 82,764 sqft lot single_family.
Is 5 Gardiners Bay Dr a flip candidate?
No — 5 Gardiners Bay Dr does not appear in our flips dataset.
Is 5 Gardiners Bay Dr a tax-appeal candidate?
No — 5 Gardiners Bay Dr is not currently flagged as a tax-appeal candidate.
Forecast for this area
ZIP-area linear projection — not a per-property automated valuationQuarterly trend
+7.2%
Implied 1-yr
+29.0%
2026 Q3
$3.07M
2026 Q4
$3.22M
ZIP 11964 — Median Price History + Forecast
Explore nearby
Geography
Other properties on Gardiners Bay Dr