59 Tuthill Dr
Shelter Island, NY 11964
3 bd 3 ba 3,999 sqft Built 1935 Lot 78,408 sqft single_family
No recorded sales
Location
Timeline: Sale, Listing & Tax History
Recorded events
No recorded events
No sale or listing events are on file for this property.
Tax assessment history
| Year | Building | Land | Total assessed | Tax paid |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2025 | $1,129,000 | $828,000 | $1,957,000 | $13,659 |
| 2024 | $1,129,000 | $828,000 | $1,957,000 | $12,968 |
| 2023 | $1,129,000 | $828,000 | $1,957,000 | $12,478 |
| 2022 | $1,129,000 | $828,000 | $1,957,000 | $6,158 |
| 2021 | $1,109,000 | $828,000 | $1,937,000 | $12,016 |
| 2020 | $1,105,500 | $827,500 | $1,933,000 | $11,791 |
| 2017 | $1,056,700 | $815,300 | $1,872,000 | $11,010 |
| 2016 | $1,069,200 | $735,800 | $1,805,000 | $10,835 |
| 2015 | $1,098,800 | $532,800 | $1,631,600 | $9,751 |
| 2014 | $1,023,600 | $518,400 | $1,542,000 | $9,399 |
| 2013 | $971,600 | $518,400 | $1,490,000 | $9,055 |
| 2012 | $520,000 | $540,000 | $1,060,000 | $6,404 |
| 2011 | $179,000 | $576,000 | $755,000 | $4,466 |
| 2010 | $144,000 | $576,000 | $720,000 | $3,779 |
| 2008 | $69,000 | $737,100 | $806,100 | $3,762 |
| 2007 | $84,000 | $685,700 | $769,700 | $3,599 |
| 2006 | $140,500 | $600,000 | $740,500 | $3,776 |
Property facts
Year built
1935
Property type
single_family
Stories
1
Beds
3
Baths
3
Living area
3,999 sqft
Lot size
78,408 sqft
ZIP code
11964
City
Shelter Island
Street
Tuthill Dr
Coordinates
41.07553, -72.27930
Comparable properties nearby
Block-level micro-comps
Same street, ±3 house numbers, sold in the last 24 monthsFrequently asked questions
When did 59 Tuthill Dr last sell?
No public-record sale is on file for 59 Tuthill Dr.
What is the current tax assessment for 59 Tuthill Dr?
The most recent total assessment for 59 Tuthill Dr (year 2025) is $1,957,000 with $13,659 in property tax.
When was 59 Tuthill Dr built?
59 Tuthill Dr was built in 1935.
How does 59 Tuthill Dr compare to others on Tuthill Dr?
We track 7 other properties on Tuthill Dr. Browse the list under "Other properties on Tuthill Dr" to compare beds, baths, and sale history.
What are the property facts for 59 Tuthill Dr?
59 Tuthill Dr is a 3 bed, 3 bath, 3,999 sqft, 78,408 sqft lot single_family.
Is 59 Tuthill Dr a flip candidate?
No — 59 Tuthill Dr does not appear in our flips dataset.
Is 59 Tuthill Dr a tax-appeal candidate?
No — 59 Tuthill Dr is not currently flagged as a tax-appeal candidate.
Forecast for this area
ZIP-area linear projection — not a per-property automated valuationQuarterly trend
+7.2%
Implied 1-yr
+29.0%
2026 Q3
$3.07M
2026 Q4
$3.22M
ZIP 11964 — Median Price History + Forecast
Explore nearby
Geography
Other properties on Tuthill Dr